![]() |
Jeff, I hope this reply finds you well. Obviously, you're confused. Concerning your last paragraph: If the Right Wrist remains Level and Bent throughout the Backstroke and Downstroke and leads the Club into impact, then how does the Uncocking Left Wrist Increase the Speed of the Clubhead greater than that which has already been provided by the Right Forearm? It's not a trick question.
You didn't need to go through all of that research just to find out that most pro's have hands decelerating before impact. You could've just asked me. If you want to use the pro's for research in how to compete on tour, I'm all for it. But if you think that by studying the way the pro's swing that you'll uncover a secret, then good luck and when we meet on the other side, you can tell me all about it. If you want to believe that the only way to swing is by dumping all of the energy on the ball at an impact location then go ahead. Impact is incidental. But explain why some golfers have the club twisted around their bodies at the end of their swing. Is that Fall-out? :laughing9 Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Daryl
You wrote-: "I hope this reply finds you well. Obviously, you're confused. Concerning your last paragraph: If the Right Wrist remains Level and Bent throughout the Backstroke and Downstroke and leads the Club into impact, then how does the Uncocking Left Wrist Increase the Speed of the Clubhead greater than that which has already been provided by the Right Forearm?" I have no idea what you are talking about! In a swinger, the club release phenomenon occurs passively due a centrifugal action (law of the flail - law of the double pendulum swing model). The right forearm does not apply any swing power or actively influence the club release action. You write-: "So Jeff, did he just say to blast the Left Arm off of the Chest at the Beginning of the Downstroke? Where is that? I must be misreading the Downstroke Sequence. I changed the text to red so that it won't take you too long to find it." I never stated that the left arm must be blasted off the chest wall at the beginning of the downswing. I stated that the left arm gets passively blasted off the chest wall when the pivot action subsides and that usually happens in the mid-downswing. Here is a video of Hogan's PA#4 release - note at what point in the downswing Hogan's left arm starts to move away from his chest wall. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loJJ0qmDQxY Here is a more precise rendition of the timing of Hogan's PA#4 release. ![]() It is my opinion that Hogan's PA#4 is being released in the yellow colored zone (image 2). Jeff. |
Quote:
Quote:
#4 is Body power and as long as the Pivot is leading and pulling the Left arm, then the left arm (body power) is still contributing. If it gets "passively blasted" off the chest wall when the pivot action subsides, then perhaps it wasn't pushed off the Chest but rather it Accelerated away from the Chest as in Momentum Transfer. The pivot is providing centripetal acceleration which induces and sustains that throwout (centrifugal). Quote:
Quote:
My Illustration is correct.:) My ART lives. |
Daryl
You wrote-: "I claim that the #4 Accumulator is still seeking its in-line condition while the #2 Accumulator has already become in-line. And because it's seeking its in-line condition, #4 is still Active after #2 has been spent as long as the Pivot train is still operating." What is your definition of the in-line condition of PA#4? At what point in the swing does PA#4 reach its in-line condition, and where in the TGM book does Homer define that in-line condition? You also wrote-: "Extensor Action should be used to prevent the Left Arm from Releasing too early." Where in the TGM book does Homer state that extensor action should be used to prevent an early release of PA#4. Here is a perfect example of a swinger's action - using PAs 4:2:3 in the optimum sequence. There is no right forerarm action or extensor action in his swing, and he has no problem with releasing PA#4 too early. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uUTk7m5PozQ Jeff. |
Quote:
Sometimes you'll see golfers let go of the club with their right hand after impact or unbend or flip with their right hand in an attempt to prevent the right arm from restricting Left Arm Acceleration after both arms straight. |
I found the Quotes:
This is from the 1st Edition Quote:
Quote:
|
Daryl,
How do you interpret the statement "in line with the shoulders"? In a previous thread on PA#4, a number of forum members defined that in-line condition as being met when there is a 90 degree angle between the chest wall and the left arm at the left shoulder area. I have a serious problem with the idea that the pivot is still driving the left arm during the left hip clearing action - when the pivot drive direction is left and inside. I can only perceive a pivot drive being useful from a swing power perspective when the left arm/left hand/club is being driven down-and-out-and-forwards towards the ball. You also wrote-: "Sometimes you'll see golfers let go of the club with their right hand after impact or unbend or flip with their right hand in an attempt to prevent the right arm from restricting Left Arm Acceleration after both arms straight." I think that a swinger may allow the right hand to leave the club, or straighten, post-impact because they have run-out-of-right arm. In the standard followthrough (using a horizontal hinging action), the left hand is moving inside and left very fast immediately post-impact. If the right shoulder has not moved sufficiently far/fast downplane in the late downswing, it may be extremely difficult for the golfer to keep the right wrist bent (and the right palm firmly attached to the grip) all the way to the end of the followthrough (when drag loading) - especially when the club is moving very fast through impact (eg. Driver swings of Phil Mickelson, VJ Singh and Fred Couples). Jeff. |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Have you seen this? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QL_6M_xZvq0 |
Daryl,
I cannot locate 10-3-O #25. I note that 12-3-O #25 simply states "extensor action - rhythm". The 6-B-4-O photo looks like the club is at low point, or just beyond low point. I am very familiar with the Hogan video. Jeff. |
Yes Jeff. Rhythm. It only looks simply stated. Look it up.
No Jeff. 90 degrees to the Shoulders. Are your shoulders parallel to the plane-line at impact? You've seen the video? Why don't you see the Pivot swinging his arms - while still at full extension - until the clubshaft is parallel to the ground after follow through. Could the Power of his Pivot (Pivot Power) be continuing to lead and move the shoulders. Body Power? = #4 Accumulator as long as the Left Arm is against the chest. Are you even reading the Book or are you so arrogant to believe that you capture the concepts, fully understand their meaning so comprehensibly that you are able to apply them by only reading them? You know what they call someone who's just graduated medical school? ......They call him "Doctor". Give me a break. You know as well as I, that reading "it", understanding "it", and being able to apply "it" are very different types of knowledge. |
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:15 PM. |