Thanks. In that brief tape, I was amazed to see what I'm sure was a Pure Swing. I thought Homer didn't think much of the concept?
This particular Stroke is characterized by its Lagging Clubhead Takeaway and length of Backstroke; Drag Loading from the Top; and the Throwout Action of Centrifugal Force in Release. Therefore, it is clear that MizunoJoe has it nailed: Homer Kelley was Swinging.
It may surprise many to learn that Homer was not 'anti-Swinging.' In fact, he felt the Basic Pattern (12-2-0) was easier to learn than Hitting (12-1-0) and -- barring a strong inclination otherwise -- he thought it should be the first to master. In his own personal Game, Homer refused to allow himself the luxury of 'one Swing.' He was the consumate researcher and -- from Drive to Putt -- his rounds were often filled with as many different 'Swings' as he had Shots. And that was for each of the several Balls he normally put in play!
But if there ever was a guy who liked to control circumstances, it was Homer Kelley. And when pushed -- and you had to push -- he would admit his preference for the total control he exercised over the Club when Hitting. He was, in his own words...