pics of wrist impact position--anti roll?

[mattsdad]

No sir. I meant FOR because the need for Swivel is eliminated as well as Horizontal Hinging. With the Left Hand "pre-turned" to the Plane then there is no need for all the required Roll of 10-2-B.

12 piece,

I'm a little confused. Your first post said:

"All that being said . . . There are some particularly those on the Darkside that actually recommend a Turned Left Hand BECAUSE it eliminates the need for any Swiveling PRIOR TO the Imapct Interval. Thus ELIMINATING what could be percieved as an 'unnecessary variable.' So you just have the Left Hand Turned to the Plane and it just rides the Plane Uncocks ONLY, which is 'throwing the Clubface at the ball.'

So an strong arguement could be made to support the bold statement."

I read this to mean that a 10-2-D grip with its attendant lack of roll can be argued to be the preferred variation. However, the bold portion of the original post indicated that the "anti-roll" grip requires better timing than (I presume) Standard Wrist Action and therefore would not be preferred. I have reproduced the bold portion of the original post below.

Quote from the author (TGM-educated)
"An antiroll wrist position at impact (where the lead wrist is flat but rolled to the right for a right-handed player) will counterbalance a closed face. One can play using this variation, but like the "rolled" position of a weak grip, requires perfect timing and is consequently subject to under or over correction on the downswing."

Am I missing something?

RT

[12 piece bucket]

12 piece,

I'm a little confused. Your first post said:



I read this to mean that a 10-2-D grip with its attendant lack of roll can be argued to be the preferred variation. However, the bold portion of the original post indicated that the "anti-roll" grip requires better timing than (I presume) Standard Wrist Action and therefore would not be preferred. I have reproduced the bold portion of the original post below.




Am I missing something?

RT

Sorry I re-read the statement in bold. I'm not sure I know what the heck it is saying. But all I'm saying is that it could be argued that 10-2-D could be a better grip for some than 10-2-B due to reducing the variable of Swiveling. I think Mac O'Grady actually was a proponent of this.

Sorry if I have confused the issue at hand. But again my position is that 10-2-D with the Turned Left Hand ain't necessarily a bad grip choice.

[hue]

Sorry I re-read the statement in bold. I'm not sure I know what the heck it is saying. But all I'm saying is that it could be argued that 10-2-D could be a better grip for some than 10-2-B due to reducing the variable of Swiveling. I think Mac O'Grady actually was a proponent of this.
b

Mac O'Grady suffered from over acceleration issues in the downstroke which leads to loss of club head lag which means the shaft and club head is doing funny stiff closing coming into impact. The stronger left hand grip will help negate the effects of this but really we should all be striving to maintain and sustain club head lag rather than building in modifications to deal will the loss of it in the downstroke . Keep the swing on plane in the downstroke, have a flat wrist at impact and sustain club head lag past the ball until both arms are straight and there is no left shot. IMO that is the real anti left way of doing things .

[annikan skywalker]

Mac O'Grady suffered from over acceleration issues in the downstroke which leads to loss of club head lag which means the shaft and club head is doing funny stiff closing coming into impact. The stronger left hand grip will help negate the effects of this but really we should all be striving to maintain and sustain club head lag rather than building in modifications to deal will the loss of it in the downstroke . Keep the swing on plane in the downstroke, have a flat wrist at impact and sustain club head lag past the ball until both arms are straight and there is no left shot. IMO that is the real anti left way of doing things .

Suffering??? The only thing suffering here .....is the Ball!!!



Where is the loss of clubhead lag here?...Over-Acceleration?

Perhaps we all suffer from the "menace of over acceleration" from time to time...but Mac is definately not suffering here!!!

[mattsdad]

Sorry I re-read the statement in bold. I'm not sure I know what the heck it is saying. But all I'm saying is that it could be argued that 10-2-D could be a better grip for some than 10-2-B due to reducing the variable of Swiveling. I think Mac O'Grady actually was a proponent of this.

Sorry if I have confused the issue at hand. But again my position is that 10-2-D with the Turned Left Hand ain't necessarily a bad grip choice.

12 piece,

Thanks. That's what I thought you were trying to say.

RT