Got “It” consistant! I fixed the left arm seperation and the take away by working out the take away. I was trying to roll the face from the get go and had no shoulder or hip movement. I found by keeping the face looking at the ball longer you have to use the upper trunk and the left arm does what is supost to. In this new position I can roll the club up and back now with no left arm seperation and turn the hips to bring the hands back to the aiming point with little throw away, and with a more crisp sound like I used to have. Now my bad shots seem to be when I try to hit it too hard and get the hands involved, gets a little heavey! or occational thin! So this is where the tempo and rythem come in and leave the pivot do the work..