He was so far over plane that I was trying to get him to position the Forearm "On Plane"- pointing at the Plane Line. It made a drastic difference in his ability to find the Plane. Next time, I'll be shooting for something closer to Pitch.
He said he'd been playing golf most of his life, and every lesson he'd ever taken the instructor would tell him that he was "over the top". He said he had never seen his club "On Plane". I told him he never would again, unless the Right Forearm pointed at the Plane Line. (Slight exaggeration, but he understood the point) He told me that he felt like an idiot at address, but if it put the club On Plane, he'd do it for the rest of his life.
What is the wrap on his right forearm for...is that an injury possibly caused by poor mechanics over many years?
He told me that it always hurt when he played, so he started wearing it to help with the pain. I'll be interested to get his feedback after a couple of weeks to see if the pain goes away.