[kmmcnabb]

I have both and prefer the swing rite which is adjustable so you can increase clubhead speed. I agree you can listen to the sound the club makes but the swing rite aids shows exactly where you reach maximum speed. I didn't like swing setter for reasons outlined in other others on this site. It promotes early wrist cock (forceful to get ball to click) and other than that it does very little for the price tag.

Best things I have purchased to work on swing have been impact bag, and tac tic. I use both religiously. I do like the speed stik for helping me feel lag pressure and building up speed but you can also do that with a heavy club (which I also have).

I have more golf gizmos than you can shake a club at and I get bored with most in a week or so (except impact bag and tac tic).