[okie]

I would say all of the above OB. Crucible, it could be that your clubface is square to the arc and "open" to the target line, or square but visually open. Don't forget that the clubface need only be square at seperation, not impact (there is an impact interval afterall) I was (and on occasion still am) plagued with a pull, especially with the short irons (more hook face) Then I read 2-J-1. Take your grip at impact fix...take your grip at impact fix. Then going to an adjusted address aligment (bent left wrist/flat right wrist)will nullify the uber-open looking clubface.