[6bmike]

Right Arm Swinging....alive and well in 10-11-1-0 just look under the phrase "True Swing" RIGHT ARM (7-19) or left Arm.

After Right Arm Swinging with a weighted club.....my right elbow feels fine. No elbow problems here....


My question to the class....Why did Homer associateTrue Swinging with the Right Arm???


DG

Because:

Homer used the term “true” with the Swing Stroke when the stroke used CF to release the clubhead. A Swinger can still use a hands manipulated Swing Stroke and be called a Swinger- but not a true Swinger. Homer also said that Swingers that use hands manipulation have more options and preferred this manner because of the increased options available. Homer also stated that the use of 6-b-1-D never makes the right arm totally passive. Not totally active in pushing but not totally inert, either.

But you mention “True Swinging,” so lets stay with that...

So, the right arm can be a “True Swing” Stroke pattern, according to the way Homer uses the word “true.” Lets read 7-19- last paragraph, first sentence-

“The “Right Arm Swing” is simply 10-3-K with loosened Wrists (7-1) and longitudinal acceleration using 7-19-3 above.”

And the last sentence reads-

“So, if there is a twinge in the elbow, you are Swinging your Right Arm.”
Top notch endorsement, huh?

Its only connection to 10-3-K is that the right arm needs to be the center of the swing, using Push Elbow both with loosened wrists, most likely with a slight bend in the left wrist And it might twinge the elbow. But it is a “True Swing” procedure never the less.

Patrick’s point was that ‘right arm thrusting is NOT compatible with swinging.’
You have to agree since both Homer and yourself call “ true right arm swinging” one with loosened wrists -and that isn’t thrusting. Correct?.