[whip]

I'll give u that and I understand the left shoulder is pulling upward however wether u meant it as a deliberate action or not this what golfers are reading and homer wants u to swing the hands down plane down down down. Sure the hand path of golfers may not ever be a straight line as in the straight line delivery path but the effort is a straight line and other instances the effort of what your Trying to accomplish for the desired results is what matters even if sometimes it is not as literal as some of the things in the book. Homer Said to not be a hacker u had to have a flat left wrist does this mean if u don't have a flat left wrist then u absolutely cannot hit a golf ball with power and accuracy. No it doesn't he cant say that but would I recommend otherwise, no would I recommend pulling the hands upward before impact, no I would tell any student to hit down an through the ball with a strong focus on the word down, maybe incidentally his hands will be minutely on the upswing at impact for a driver. fine but the effort should always be down and out.