Nah. I would tell them to see you for advice on getting in touch with their natural swings.
Well, perhaps if you read what I typed
'Experimenting for a little bit doesn't really hurt, but you do have to trust that your natural motion may be the best way for you.'
I'm just curious as to what your thoughts would be if Jack or Fred or Ben came to you and started asking about the right elbow at the top of the swing? Would you tell them to reverse every natural instinct?
I just don't think your quotes from the book really apply to the situation at hand, not to forget that you took my quote out of context.