So, the Right Shoulder can have direction, because it can move toward a Plane Line. There's no specific direction in "swinging left", as there's no direction for the Left Shoulder or the Hips. The Hips rotate more on a horizontal plane than on the inclined Plane. Therefore, giving them any direction is haphazard.
I think these ideas 12 Piece has explained is huge to my understanding of swinging left...
I create that perverted axis tilt YODA talked about, my right shoulder goes down with no out, and I'm stuck swinging way out to the right. No possible way to get left no matter how hard I try, and no way to get on top of the ball with my sternum.
Getting the right shoulder to go OUT along with down opens my shoulders slightly at impact, and allows me to swing back up the plane line (swing left) instead of out to the right, causing either massive blocks or the quackers.
Still excited a day later!
Kevin
__________________
I could be wrong. I have been before, and will be again.